Rick's Blog

Aragon East in the Raw

Rick Outzen

Here are the raw scores on the Aragon East proposals:

Townsend

Downtown Pensacola Hotel 47
Esplanade 64
Hawkshaw Eastside 85
Technology Bay 78
Technology Bay at Hawkshaw 90

Wiggins

Downtown Pensacola Hotel 49
Esplanade 65
Hawkshaw Eastside 73
Technology Bay 81
Technology Bay at Hawkshaw 90
Fogg

Downtown Pensacola Hotel 49
Esplanade 59
Hawkshaw Eastside 82
Technology Bay 64
Technology Bay at Hawkshaw 93
DeSorbo

Downtown Pensacola Hotel 28
Esplanade 53
Hawkshaw Eastside 70
Technology Bay 58
Technology Bay at Hawkshaw 62

Cannada-Wynn

Downtown Pensacola Hotel 45
Esplanade 91
Hawkshaw Eastside 91
Technology Bay 79
Technology Bay at Hawkshaw 80

Donovan

Downtown Pensacola Hotel 43
Esplanade 59
Hawkshaw Eastside 84
Technology Bay 73
Technology Bay at Hawkshaw 58

Jerralds

Downtown Pensacola Hotel 35
Esplanade 41
Hawkshaw Eastside 94
Technology Bay 41
Technology Bay at Hawkshaw 40

Nobles

Downtown Pensacola Hotel 27
Esplanade 40
Hawkshaw Eastside 50
Technology Bay 48
Technology Bay at Hawkshaw 81

Smith

Downtown Pensacola Hotel 56
Esplanade 57
Hawkshaw Eastside 74
Technology Bay 78
Technology Bay at Hawkshaw 76

Wu

Downtown Pensacola Hotel 49
Esplanade 57
Hawkshaw Eastside 86
Technology Bay 63
Technology Bay at Hawkshaw 95

RAW TOTALS

  1. Hawkshaw Eastside 789
  2. Technology Bay at Hawkshaw 765
  3. Technology Bay 663
  4. Esplanade 586
  5. Downtown Pensacola Hotel 428

DISCARD HIGH & LOW

  1. Hawkshaw Eastside 645
  2. Technology Bay at Hawkshaw 630
  3. Technology Bay 541
  4. Esplanade 455
  5. Downtown Pensacola Hotel 345

Median

  1. Hawkshaw Eastside 83
  2. Technology Bay at Hawkshaw 80.5
  3. Technology Bay 68.5
  4. Esplanade 58
  5. Downtown Pensacola Hotel 46

MEAN

  1. Hawkshaw Eastside 78.9
  2. Technology Bay at Hawkshaw 76.5
  3. Technology Bay 66.3
  4. Esplanade 58.6
  5. Downtown Pensacola Hotel 42.8

——————————

RO NOTE: Councilman John Jerralds really skewed the votes by ranking Hawkshaw Eastside 53 points higher than any other proposal. Nobles was almost just as bad as he ranked Technology Bay at Hawkshaw 31 points higher than Hawkshaw Eastside.

If you take Jerralds and Nobles votes out – Hawkshaw Eastside (645) still beats Technology Bay at Hawkshaw (644) by one vote.

The voting process was set prior to the RFP being awarded. We have to live with it.

Exit mobile version