Accountability | Escambia County Commission, Mayor D.C. Reeves
Since 2023, the Escambia County Commission has heard at least a half dozen presentations on renovating the Pensacola Bay Center. The only formal vote I can find is a $10 million maintenance package in May 2024.
The Escambia County Board of County Commissioners has spent nearly three years discussing how to fix the aging Pensacola Bay Center, and the public record shows one formal vote.
- That vote approved about $10 million in tourist development tax money for deferred maintenance. Every other step, including a $189 million proposal and a $74 million first phase, ended with commissioners saying they were interested and taking no vote.
Here is what the record shows, and what remains unanswered as a new board takes office.
The timeline
March 2024: More study, more money. The Pensacola News Journal reported that the assessment estimated about $72.5 million in needs over seven years and nearly $140 million over 20. Commissioners agreed to pay Populous Inc. an additional $49,000 to refine those numbers. County Administrator Wes Moreno said the county wanted to keep working with ASM Global and reduce the Bay Center subsidy. No timeline was set for funding decisions.
Spring 2024: The one vote. WKRG reported that commissioners approved $10 million for Bay Center improvements over four years, paid from the tourist development tax. The schedule: $3 million in year one for sound, lighting, parking lot repaving, fencing and retractable seating; $3,011,000 in year two for the end-of-life ice plant; $2,310,000 in year three; and $1,670,200 in year four.
August and September 2024: A $90 million idea. The Tourist Development Council (TDC), which only recommends, heard a proposal for up to $60 million for an indoor sports facility at Ashton Brosnaham Park and $30 million in tourist tax money for the Bay Center. The TDC recommended it in September. Final decisions belong to the commission. At the time, a TDC member questioned spending $43 million on upgrades without an outside physical study.
April 2025: Four options. NorthEscambia.com reported the commission had considered four concept designs ranging from $22 million to $104 million for the Bay Center alone.
April/May 2025: Pensacola Mayor D.C. Reeves injects himself into the commissioners’ discussions. He asked the county to collaborate on a comprehensive plan for renovating the Bay Center and possibly developing the surrounding area. The city would pay for a district master plan, and he suggested a joint meeting at City Hall within 30 to 45 days to pick a planning firm. Reeves then pushed for a joint city-county task force, and Kohler responded with a resolution for an 11-member advisory committee.
July 10, 2025: A joint workshop with the city. Chair Mike Kohler and Mayor D.C. Reeves said they wanted to move quickly. According to my report on the meeting, $25 million was already committed through a bank loan and about $75 million remained in bonding capacity. Kohler warned that state legislation could affect tourist tax dollars if the project was not advanced by July 1, 2026. The decision on a citizen advisory committee was postponed, and no formal votes were taken.
January 23, 2026: The $189 million plan. Legends Global, the Bay Center’s operator, presented a market and feasibility study. The package totaled $189 million, including $71 million for arena renovations. Consultants projected $59.2 million in total annual economic impact. WUWF reported that commissioners did not take a final vote.
April 16, 2026: A consensus, but no vote. At a joint meeting with the Pensacola City Council and the mayor, the numbers on the table were about $71 million for the renovation, $84 million to $86 million for a new event center, and about $30 million for a second ice sheet. Commissioner Steven Barry estimated bonding capacity at about $150 million. Chair Ashlee Hofberger summarized the direction: renovate, add an event center, keep negotiating a public-private deal on the second ice sheet, and have the city handle parking. The meeting produced no vote.
August 6, 2026: A smaller first phase. At another Committee of the Whole workshop, staff recommended a phased approach starting with a roughly $74 million first phase to renovate the existing building. Staff will prepare a request for proposals to find a long-term private development partner. WUWF reported that no votes were taken.
November 17, 2026: A new board. Joe Vinson and Mike Kohler were sworn in, with Vinson replacing Hofberger in District 4. The new board inherits an unapproved first phase and an unsettled agreement with the city.
What the record raises
- The interlocal agreement surprised the people who must approve it. WEAR reported that a draft agreement giving the city final say over what happens on the land had been approved by county legal in June, but none of the commissioners had seen it. Commissioner May said he did not know about the agreement or the meetings. Reeves later pulled the item from the City Council agenda to give the county time to review it.
- The county does not control the land. County Attorney Geoff Brodersen told commissioners the property is under a long-term lease involving the City of Pensacola and the Florida Department of Transportation, and major changes need written approval from both. That fact was decades old before the first consultant was hired.
- The studies came from the operator. The $189 million plan was commissioned by Legends Global, which runs the building. At the April joint meeting, City Council President Allison Patton argued the procurement should be run by someone without a stake, since Legends may bid on managing the new facilities.
- The subsidy question has not gone away. At the July 2025 workshop, Kohler said the county had invested over $10 million from 2020 to 2025, with an annual operating subsidy of about $1.3 million. His words: “We can’t keep losing money.”
Where this stands. The Bay Center opened in 1985, and the county has now spent three years studying what to do with it. The commission has the tourist tax money and a consensus on direction. What it does not have is a vote on a plan.
- County Administrator Wes Moreno hasn’t brought back an interlocal agreement to the Board of County Commissioners. Mayor D.C. Reeves has not presented one to the Pensacola City Council. The community is left in limbo.
Mayor asks BCC for a joint comprehensive plan for Bay Center area
