Rick's Blog

Overnights for Hofberger’s cartoon options not good

Option 3

Readers are not impressed with Commissioner Ashlee Hofberger’s “new” renderings for her proposed new gateway to Pensacola Beach. The options boil down to Innisfree logo (1), Beach Ball (2), or Dolphin (3).

 

From Instagram:

“Nope, nope and hell nope.

“Literally neither. Is it the drive to Disney World?!?!?”

“These are awful.”

“Terrible. There is plenty of great local creative talent. They need to hire a professional.”

“Woof. Someone take away this person’s Canva.”

“Is this serious?”

“First on still incorporates part of the Innisfree logo.”

“I can’t believe with all the local talent they are going to spend 1.4m on this!”

“2 — if these are the only options.”

“Option zero”

“Ummm this seems like a good opportunity to open up a submission from local artists.”

From Facebook:

“No sign that’s my Vote!”

“Why can’t we vote for dressing rooms, no additional hotels, and more parking?”

Like everyone here, I think the sign is a waste of money. And with these amateur designs, may as well just say welcome to cheeseball beach. We have a sign coming into the beach welcoming you—the lit-up one. It’s mid-century modern feeling. If you absolutely have to still do this project then please hire Chris Bogan Creative to design it as these aren’t it. And I know I’ll catch hell for this, but that beach ball? Never liked it. It’s cheesy. Pensacola Beach should spend that money on a rebrand identity update. Stylistically, we should embrace and build off of our mid-century development era and the already great lit-up mid-century welcome sign we have. We need a more modern, clean look, not cartoons and bad fonts.”

“You come over the bridge you know you’re on Pensacola Beach why do we need to pollute it with more signage.”
“No sign, Please!
“Peace and love—but these designs just aren’t hitting the mark. The font and colors don’t reflect the beauty of our beaches, and the type layout feels unpolished—almost like it was done by someone without much design experience. I don’t want to hurt any feelings, but it just doesn’t seem to sell our beach in a way that’s interesting or inviting. This really needs a more thoughtful and professional approach.”
“No sign, please! It’s unnecessary.”
“Build more restroom facilities… something we can all benefit from.”
“I don’t like any of them.”
“A ridiculous and ugly way to spend money. Trash the entire idea and use the money for something useful.”
“Stupidest idea….AGAIN”
“Waste of money”
It’s like amateur hour— trying to get away from paying for a professional designer, which would be minimal in the overall cost of construction. Quit with the “contests” already. You will not get a design everyone would agree on, but by paying a professional, you’ll get a professional designer.”

Well, the online form makes you choose an option or you can’t submit. I was trying to write in the comments that I choose none of the above. The design is terrible and all

“Looks the same whether it’s 1, 2, or 3. They need to go back to the drawing board. Can we not get artists/architects/engineers anyone who is talented to submit renderings? I’m sure we would get something better and less theme park-looking.”
Exit mobile version