Escambia County Schools
Leonard: Closing Lincoln Park and Warrington Won’t Right-Size Escambia Schools
At a Nov. 12 board workshop, administrators said the SAZAC committee is on track to finish attendance zones for both schools. Board members spent just as much time on what comes next.
- Escambia School Superintendent Keith Leonard summed up the difficult decisions ahead: “Sometimes leadership is lonely. You got to make a decision, and you’ve got to decide where to start.”
The irony is that the district is having unprecedented success, having achieved its first “A” for the last school year.
- Leonard said. “We’ve had great success academically. We have really good academic momentum. We want to do everything we can to keep that in place.”
The superintendent added that vouchers complicate any closure plan. He said, “It doesn’t do any good to close three, five or 10 if their choice ends up being not to attend any of our schools.”
- Right-sizing the school district could mean losing as many as three elementary schools, one middle school and one high school, or about five elementary schools.
- Board chair Tom Harrell estimated the district has 14 more schools and 600 more employees than similar districts.
Superintendent Keith Leonard told the Escambia County School Board at last week’s workshop that closing Lincoln Park and Warrington elementary schools will not right-size the district.
- Asked directly by Board Member David Williams whether the plan does the job, Leonard answered, “The answer to that question is no.”
Board Chair Tom Harrell called the two closures “the first step” in a process he expects to continue “for some time.”
- The exchange came during an update on the Student Attendance Zone Advisory Committee, or SAZAC, which Williams requested after hearing from constituents in District 3. Assistant Superintendent Shawn Dennis, who leads the SAZAC process, briefed the board on the committee’s progress.
Dennis said the committee has met four times and is holding back-to-back meetings. Its only task is to draw attendance zones for the superintendent’s two recommendations: closing Lincoln Park and closing Warrington.
The Numbers
- Savings: Dennis put the operating cost at roughly $2.8 million per school, or $5.6 million combined. Harrell cited a district financial report showing $2.851 million for Lincoln Park and $3 million for Warrington.
- Enrollment: The district has about 32,600 to 33,000 students and roughly 38,600 seats of traditional capacity, leaving about 5,500 empty seats.
- Lincoln Park: Leonard said it has 196 students, possibly including pre-K, in a building with a capacity of about 300. Both schools have fewer than 300 students.
- Leaving the zone: Dennis said, “Less than 55% of the students that reside in Lincoln Park attendance zone attend Lincoln Park, but they go to 27 other programs in schools in our district.” Warrington’s share is slightly higher.
- Money-losing schools: Harrell said 91% of district schools are operating at a loss, up from 46 of 58 centers a year ago.
Is District 3 Being Targeted?
Williams laid out the history behind his concern. From 2002 to 2019, the district closed 10 facilities in District 3, six in District 5, three in District 2, one in District 4 and none in District 1.
“I think all five districts ought to feel the pain.”
David Williams, District 3
Dennis said the pattern comes down to where students live and how old the buildings are. He noted that earlier closures in District 5 included Molino Park Elementary.
- “It had nothing to do with which district they were in. It’s just the enrollment numbers that were there for the economics of scale,” Dennis said.
- He added, “It is simply a matter of student density where the students reside.”
Leonard said he asked SAZAC to look at only these two sites, chosen because each has fewer than 300 students and many zoned families have opted out. Dennis said the choice “had nothing to do with which district they were in.”
What Full Right-Sizing Would Take
Dennis offered the math.
- Using the district’s preferred sizes of 800 students for an elementary, 1,200 for a middle school and 2,000 for a high school, a full right-sizing would mean closing three elementaries, one middle school and one high school, or about five elementaries. He called that a conservative estimate, since few existing schools hold 800 students.
- In 2006, the district found it had 30% too many schools and closed six elementaries, three middle schools and one high school.
Harrell said districts of Escambia’s size typically operate about 44 schools. Escambia has 58 centers. He also noted that a comparable district with 39,000 students has 4,400 employees, while Escambia has more than 5,000.
- He said, “It’s not going to happen with closing two schools.”
The board chair added, “It breaks my heart as being a 40 year veteran in this district that we’ve gotten to a point now where we’re having to look at the number of employees we have, the number of the schools.”
Who Decides
Harrell and Board Member Kevin Adams both pushed back on a public misperception. SAZAC does not decide which schools close. Dennis described the committee as producing the “roadmap,” showing what a closure would look like measured against the 12 assessments. The superintendent then makes a recommendation, and the board has the final say.
Adams recalled the earlier round of 10 closures as “not a good time.” “Nobody will see their community school closed,” he said.
- He warned that falling enrollment from the state’s voucher program is hitting all 67 Florida districts. He said, “This ain’t the end of it.”
What’s Next
- SAZAC aims to finish Lincoln Park zones at its next meeting or the one after, then move to Warrington.
- Leonard hopes to bring a first iteration to the board for a vote in December. If not, January, with a final vote after that. A special meeting is possible.
- Leonard said he will meet with the affected school staff again, but only after he can tell them where their students would go. He expects that in November or early December.
