Podcast | Pensacola
Civic Dialogues Puts 100 Pensacola Residents in the Room
More than 2,500 residents submitted ideas. Nearly 100,000 votes were cast. This week, about 100 of them sit down on Zoom to talk about the future of Pensacola’s parks.
Anyone who has covered local government knows the problem. The people who show up at the meeting aren’t always the people who speak for the community. The loudest voices set the agenda, and the folks working a second shift or picking up kids never get heard.
- That is the gap a program called Civic Dialogues says it is built to close, and it is now underway in Pensacola in partnership with the city. On the latest We Don’t Color on the Dog, I sat down with Erika Soto Lamb and David Rosenthal of Civic Dialogues, with Shannon Nickinson joining us, to find out how it works.
“Elected officials do not have an easy way to hear from their residents or a representative group of residents.”
Erika Soto Lamb, Civic Dialogues
How the Process Works
Step one: ideas and votes. For the past couple of months, Pensacola residents have posted ideas on the issues that matter most to them and voted on one another’s suggestions. Rosenthal said the effort has drawn more than 2,500 residents submitting ideas and almost 100,000 cumulative votes.
Step two: the live dialogue. A group of about 100 residents who volunteered will meet on a Zoom call this week. They will hear research and background on the issue, then work through it together and decide what recommendations to move forward.
What happens next. Rosenthal said the recommendations will be processed and published, shared with the participants and the broader community, and delivered directly to the city. There is no firm date yet, but the goal is to work with the city to put the ideas into action.
It’s Not a Poll. It’s Bridging.
I raised the obvious question. Isn’t this just polling? Lamb and Rosenthal say no. Popularity alone doesn’t decide which ideas rise to the top. The platform uses a method called bridging, which looks for where people from different groups agree.
- Ideas are scored by how they fare across groups, such as Republicans, independents and Democrats.
- The bridging score is the minimum score across any group, so an idea can’t rise on the strength of one camp alone.
- Rosenthal said the team can also set party labels aside and use voting patterns to see where residents agree, including views on preservation versus modernization.
Pensacola’s recent election results show a city with several distinct voting blocs. A tool that finds agreement across them is worth watching.
The Topic: Parks
The subject for this week’s dialogue is Pensacola’s park system. Rosenthal said parks emerged as an area with a lot of common ground, regardless of political party. Considering how many parks the city has, and how quickly the topic stirs up interest whenever it comes up, that fits.
The bottom line: Whether Civic Dialogues delivers will depend on what the city does with the recommendations. The participants will meet this week. Residents and the city will see the results once they are processed and published, and I’ll be watching how Pensacola responds.