Escambia County Commission
Kohler on the Library Fight: “She Didn’t Meet the Qualifications”
Back on the dais, Commissioner Mike Kohler explains being the lone vote against County Administrator Wes Moreno’s pick to head the library system, how he ranked Christal Bell-Rivera’s resume against the board’s top pick, and the need to settle the governance question before new members are seated.
Escambia County Commissioner Mike Kohler, who returned to the board Tuesday, says he knew something was wrong with the hiring of the West Florida Public Library director before the commission ever voted. Kohler told me he reviewed the Library Board of Governance’s rankings, saw that Christal Bell-Rivera finished fourth, read the resumes and concluded she did not meet the qualifications “you would expect in a normal library process.”
- Kohler joined me on the podcast the day after he and Commissioner Joe Vinson were sworn in. The conversation covered the library board, the stalled Pensacola Bay Center and the new chair. The library fight got the most time, and it produced the most news.
The Library Hiring: What Kohler Says Happened
The rankings. The Library Board of Governance unanimously recommended Bradley Vinson. Kohler said Bell-Rivera was ranked fourth. He said he asked for the rankings himself and compared them with the resumes.
- A background in hiring librarians. Kohler said he has hired a librarian before, during his time at the Navy hospital, and knows what a residency program expects. That is why the resumes did not sit right with him.
A heated exchange. County Administrator Wes Moreno was in the hospital at the time, so Kohler took his concerns to the acting county administrator, Debbie Bowers. He said the conversation “got pretty heated.” Staff argued that Bell-Rivera met the county’s qualifications. Kohler’s response was blunt.
“I said, ‘You changed the policy. So she meets it based on what is now, but it’s not the best qualified.'”
- That matches what I reported: the requirements were changed in a way that made Bell-Rivera appear qualified. Kohler told staff before the meeting that he would not say how he planned to vote, “but it’s probably not gonna be the way you think.”
The vote. The commission backed Moreno’s pick, Bell-Rivera, anyway. Kohler voted no. He said afterward he congratulated her and told her there were no hard feelings. At that point, he said, he did not know what would come out in the weeks that followed.
Meetings Canceled
Moreno also canceled the Library Board of Governance’s meetings. Kohler said he never thought that should have happened. He said he did not like how the whole process went down. He has since talked with Moreno about it, and he said the administrator is moving forward.
“The canceling of the meetings I never thought should happen.”
Governing Board or Advisory Board?
The question underneath the entire dispute is whether the library board governs or only advises. Kohler said he got frustrated at a recent meeting because the backup material did not include the current bylaws. He had been reading an older version. When he went back and compared them, he found the bylaws had been changed.
- Older bylaws: Read more like an advisory board.
- Current bylaws: Read more like a governing board.
- Kohler’s position: The board makes policy, and that policy comes to the commission to be ratified or modified, the same way the Tourist Development Council and other boards operate.
Kohler said he would take what the board sends seriously, as he does with every board that brings an item to the commission. He also said the commission should settle the governance question before new members start, so they know where they stand.
Appointments. Nominees could come before the commission as soon as December, and the board may be able to meet again. Kohler said he has already reviewed the nominees and has his top four, but he declined to name them.
The Bay Center: “We’re Not Moving Fast Enough”
On the Pensacola Bay Center, Kohler did not hedge. “We’re not moving fast enough. Let’s just be honest.” He said he spoke with the mayor earlier in the day and believes the board, the city council and the mayor all want to move forward.
- The lease: The interlocal sublease runs through September 2078.
- Improvements to the center itself: Kohler said the county can make them today, with legal sign-off and city involvement.
- Add-ons: A convention center, an ice rink or anything else on the site would need a new interlocal agreement with the city. He does not expect that to be a showstopper.
- The RFP: A request for proposals for the Bay Center itself went out recently.
Kohler said the two meetings with the city went well and he is not sure why momentum faded. He said blame can be shared, including with the city. He also pointed to rumors that the state legislature may want to get into tourist development tax marketing, which is one more reason not to wait. His target is early next year, and he said he hopes he has the board’s support.
Note: At his weekly press conference yesterday, I asked Mayor D.C. Reeves if Moreno has met with him or city staff to discuss the Pensacola Bay Center and the interlocal agreement since August. Mayor Reeves said he is not aware of any conversation with County Administrator Wes Moreno and has had no feedback from commissioners or county staff.
A New Chair, and a Missed Ceremony
Commissioner Steve Strohberger took over as chair. Kohler called him a friend and a retired Navy commander who knows tough situations, and said he hopes the board avoids the name-calling and emotion of the past year.
- Kohler raised one point about the swearing-in. The outgoing chair (Ashlee Hofberger) did not pass the gavel.
- Kohler said that after taking part in change-of-command ceremonies in the Navy, he believes the vice chair should have handled it as a ceremonial hand-off. He said he did not think of it until afterward and has not raised it with Strohberger.
Kohler also got emotional during the installation. He said he spent years as an ICU and oncology nurse and has been around a lot of death. He said he is fine with showing it, and that he sees it as a sign of humanity, not weakness.
What Commissioner Kohler has called “the library debacle” has many, many parts. I urge him to take action and make a motion directing the incoming county attorney to appoint someone from the outside and truly “independent” to conduct a no-holds barred review of the library director selection process. The foundational starting point should be a comprehensive review of how the process was conducted in 2015 when Todd Humble was hired. West Florida Public Library Board of Governance (WFPL BOG) member Lori NeSmith seems to have been removed, by Mayor Reeves, and likely in violation of Resolution 2013-17 that governs operation of the board, because she has expert knowledge of the how the process was conducted in 2015. People in county government advocating for Christal Bell-Rivera to get the job appear to have wanted NeSmith silenced. Didn’t work. She continues to show up and speak truth to power. We also need a detailed review of the actual library director application documents and the process of reviewing and binning them. In January, HR Director Nikki Powell told the WFPL BOG that she and her staff were at odds over the process. Why? Her staff needs to be interviewed under oath. That part of the meeting was redacted from the meeting minutes, presumably at the order of senior county staff who may have ordered changes to the meeting minutes before the WFPL BOG saw them. I think Chairwoman Ashlee Hofberger was the mastermind behind the scheme. I had given her the benefit of the doubt until August when I spoke with her husband Grant. He made it very clear Ashlee was on some sort of venomous evangelical crusade to stop Bradley Vinson from getting the job. In addition to Hofberger and Powell, the other suspected “bad actors” are disgraced, former D4 Aide Melanie Luna (who inexplicably remains appointed to a county board notwithstanding her obvious unethical involvement in the library debacle), County Administrator Wes Moreno and Assistant County Administrators Debbie Bowers and Wes Hall. There may be even more people involved.
It is so wonderful to have a commissioner willing to speak on these issues with a good deal of candor, and the community is very lucky to have his level-headed approach on things, especially while staring down the barrel of the budget cuts coming from Amendment 3 passing.
On one point, however, I respectfully disagree with Commissioner Kohler’s analogy of the Library Board of Governance being like any other volunteer board, and using the TDC as example.
The Library Board of Governance is *not* like any other volunteer board, and nothing like how the TDC is set to function by state statute, which clearly leaves them in an advisory position in which they can only recommend, with the BCC being the final authority on TDT spending.
The LIBRARY BOARD OF GOVERNANCE IS THE POLICY MAKING AUTHORITY, as it is *clearly* defined in the interlocal agreement with the City. The interlocal agreement is the ultimate legal authority on how the WFLBOG operates.
The County Attorney at first distracted everyone by pegging the legal on the resolution red herring, which stalled understanding for a good while. After that tactic was publicly exposed, she then switched to continuing to pull focus from the interlocal by pushing comment on the by-laws, and went so far as to intentionally provide Commissioner Kohler with an outdated copy of the by laws–from 2013, if memory serves–as “preparation” for the discussion. It is frustrating to see well-meaning people get led by the nose with these tactics.
George Touart *clearly* shepherded a legal agreement with the City that created a new policy making board, and he made that explicit in his remarks to the commission. The only grey area, legally and ethically, is how much leeway the administrator has (legally) or should take (ethically) in choosing the Library Director, and anyone who goes back and watches the video again can see that Mr. Touart danced around that subject in many ways. Ultimately, on paper, he unfortunately left the door open for legal speculation–I have no doubt, with every intention of leaving himself enough legal wiggle room to operate. He stated *verbally*, however, that he wasn’t going to get into the hiring of that role, unless something “crazy” happened.
You are absolutely correct, Rick, that the board needs to have a discussion so they are clear on all this–once Will Nelson takes the reins. Continuing to employ Alison’s legal opinion on the Governance board itself, or on Wes’s legal role in the hiring of a Director, isn’t just a recipe for continued, and embarrassingly blatant, legal politicking , but, at this point, moot.